Public Safety Chess Moves

Posted on Tuesday, October 16 2007 by Heather Brandon

Mayor Ryan with Stephen LisauskasAt a meeting of the Springfield Finance Control Board today, Mayor Charles Ryan and control board executive director Stephen Lisauskas were empowered, by a unanimous vote, to appoint immediately an acting police commissioner “should the need arise.”

Following the meeting, Mayor Ryan and Lisauskas together announced that in the event of Police Commissioner Edward Flynn‘s resignation, they would appoint Deputy Chief William Fitchet as acting commissioner.

In early 2005, when Fitchet (as acting commissioner) was passed over in favor of the selection of Flynn for the top post, Mayor Ryan called Fitchet a “bridge of integrity and steadfastness” between the administration of former Police Chief Paula Meara and newly-hired Commissioner Flynn. At the time, reporter and editor G. Michael Dobbs quoted Fitchet, “I’m disappointed, but I am a professional police officer and I will continue to be a professional police officer.”

Ordinarily personnel matters would come before the full control board for approval. Board chairman Christopher Gabrieli explained, knowing the possibility that Commissioner Flynn may resign, “We felt that given the importance of public safety in Springfield—and anyplace—we need to understand the current facts as well as what would happen should there be a need to make a change.”

Finance Control Board talks with Stephen Lisauskas

The board requested that City Solicitor Edward Pikula publicly present the nuts and bolts of Commissioner Flynn’s five-year contract. “Under the first three years of the agreement,” Pikula began, “the commissioner cannot be removed unless we have just cause, defined under the statutes as basically misconduct in office. There are terms that deal with the fact that if he resigned as a result of the suggestion of the city, we would have to pay him severance pay. It would be owed if we asked for his resignation, if he did resign as a result of a suggestion—after saying, hey, I’m willing to stay—it could trigger some legal action in us owing him some severance pay.”

Mayor Ryan clarified, “I understand that if Commissioner Flynn were to resign now—by now, I mean in the next matter of weeks—that he’s entitled to no severance pay.” Correct, said Pikula. “On the other hand,” Ryan continued, “if the city—and by this I assume we’re talking the city government—formally suggests that he resign, called by office-holders, asking for resignation, that would denote a necessity to pay 12 months’ salary. Isn’t that right, in severance?” Yes, it could trigger the severance clause, conceded Pikula.

City Council President Kateri Walsh wanted to know if the commissioner is required to give the city notice of an impending resignation. “There is a 30-day notice provision,” stated Pikula, “[regarding] which the commissioner may enact a waiver, if he should decide to leave earlier.”

Board member James Morton wondered about the specifics of the matter of the “city suggesting” something. He asked, “In the contract, who is it that can suggest that he leave? Who has the authority?”

“Well, under contract, no one,” Pikula replied. “But if the city does formally request it, that can trigger the clause.”

“And the city would be…whom?” asked Morton.

“The city of Springfield,” Pikula said. “It acts through its control board, or acts through the mayor, or its executive decision-maker, or executive director of the control board, if those powers are delegated.

Below is a transcript of Mayor Ryan and Lisauskas’s briefing of members of the press.

Mayor Charles Ryan: In accordance with the vote of the control board making Mr. Lisauskas and me the board’s designees, we would like to announce that in the event that Commissioner Flynn resigns to take a new job, we will immediately appoint Deputy Chief William Fitchet as acting commissioner so that there will be no gap at all in the leadership role of the Springfield Police Department.

You may remember that when Chief [Paula] Meara resigned a little over a couple of years ago, we had the same situation occur, and at that time, Phil Puccia and I appointed Deputy Chief Fitchet, and he served as acting commissioner for seven months, the latter part of which was taken up with the nationwide search. So it will be Deputy Chief Fitchet again, if that eventuality occurs.

Ray Hershel of ABC40: Mr. Mayor, would you ask for Commissioner Flynn to resign, as—

Ryan: No, I—

Hershel: —Councilor [Domenic] Sarno has asked?

Ryan: You must not have been listening—

Hershel: I was listening.

Mayor Ryan with Stephen LisauskasRyan: —because if I do that, it may cost us $155,000. That’s an ill-advised speech to make. It’s very clear in the contract that if the city suggests, not even urges, but suggests, that he resign, that instead of no severance pay, he would get 12 months severance pay. So I’m certainly not going to do that; that’s foolhardy.

John Baibak of WHYN: Mayor, when Councilor Sarno suggested that yesterday, does he set that in motion?

Ryan: Did I—what?

Baibak: When Councilor Sarno said yesterday that he should resign, as a city official, does he set that clause in motion?

Ryan: I don’t know; that’s a legal interpretation. I certainly would hope he doesn’t do it again, and I would hope that none of his colleagues do it. It’s a very serious thing, and we’re governed by laws, and it’s a contract, and it has the force of law, so it’s not smart. So we’ll do it soberly, exactly the way the board has met today.

Peter Goonan of the Republican: What is your reaction to the news that he’s an applicant for that job in Milwaukee?

Ryan: Well, I’ve already indicated that I was disappointed, certainly, when he came here. We had enough chances to ask him, and did ask him, to make sure that he would be staying, and we would sure that he would be. And so this is something that we did not anticipate. However, he’s made this decision, and will go forward, and our job now is to keep our eye on the ball, and to act prudently on behalf of the people of Springfield.

Heather Brandon of Urban Compass: Mr. Mayor, has Commissioner Flynn expressed job dissatisfaction?

Ryan: None at all. And I think we’ve had a very fine and close working relationship. I know that I and the control board have been extremely supportive of the commissioner, and the leadership of the department. We’ve added significant funding to the department. It means more manpower, technology aides, cruisers, and the like, so I don’t think that there’s any, let’s say, internal problem that caused this. I think this is his own independent judgment and choice.

Paul Tuthill of WAMC: Given the fact that you have been so supportive of him financially, of the department, how does the fact that he’s even considering this position in Milwaukee affect your working relationship? [Listen to Tuthill's report here]

Ryan: Once I’ve gotten by expressing my disappointment, there’s really nothing more to say. It’s a free country. Men and women have the freedom of choice. This is a decision he made, and he’s answerable for it, and it doesn’t do any good to just wish him well if he gets the job, but really to immediately turn our attention to a process which will result, first of all, in an acting commissioner, and ultimately in a permanent commissioner.

Stephen Lisauskas with Mayor RyanControl Board Executive Director Stephen Lisauskas: I think as the mayor has said, and the chairman said earlier, public safety is critical for the city of Springfield, and we have now a strong police commissioner, and strong leadership, strong management in the department. If the commissioner decides, if he moves to Milwaukee or another city at some point in the future, we will have a strong interim chief, who for seven months worked as commissioner—strong performance there—and if the eventuality does come to pass, then we will have strong management and strong leadership in effect in an interim period. And then, when a permanent commissioner is appointed, we will have strong management and leadership there. As President Walsh indicated, there is going to be no break in service. There will be no break in management and leadership. The department needs to continue to move forward. It’s done a good job doing so, and we need to continue that.

Baibak: Mayor, if Flynn goes, you really have to give Fitchet the job permanently, right? Knowing his history here?

Ryan: No, no, no, we’re not there at all. Again, that will be a process. Nobody should get ahead of themselves in this. The control board did not get into that decision today. The only decision made today is we felt that we had a responsibility to announce to the public, through you, as to what would happen if, in fact, he resigns, as to whether or not there will be interim leadership—and there will be—in the person of Deputy Fitchet. But the whole process of where we go from there has not even been talked about by the control board. We’ll cross that bridge when we come to it, if we have to.

13 Responses to “Public Safety Chess Moves”

  1. Becca

    I’m in the professional recruiting business (no, not a headhunter – we are a “retained” search firm) and it is pretty common for candidates who aren’t actually looking to be a lured into “just coming to talk” about a job. That is likely what happened with Flynn. Unfortunately, our city is still just too fragile in its new growth and development for him to do such things without making it feel much bigger than it actually may be. That said, this time maybe we should just go with Fitchet if it comes down to it!!!!

  2. Sheila McElwaine

    Those who support Commissioner Flynn and his reforms are, like the Mayor, disappointed that he has been lured, as Becca puts it, into interviewing for the Milwaukee job. His reforms, while extremely promising, are far from having been institutionalized, especially given the resistance to change of any bureaucracy, governmental ones in particular and police departments most of all. Let us hope that a chastened Commissioner Flynn returns to Springfield and gets back to the business of law enforcement here for the remainder of his contract. The city does not need the turmoil and uncertainty of a search for another commissioner.

    Additionally, one wonders what ties to any hiring firm could possibly have been more important than the Commissioner’s duty of loyalty to this city which trusted him with the task of law enforcement which everybody agrees is key to our future progress.

  3. Heather Brandon http://urbancompass.net

    Becca, do you see the timing of the “luring” of Flynn to be relatively commonplace as well? I’m referring to the fact that the deadline had long since passed by the time he was brought in as a candidate, and he quickly became a finalist. In addition, this is a public sector job in the spotlight, not a quiet private sector job, so the context is different.

    Some may view the developments as a dead giveaway that he is a shoo-in for the job, especially if the people who are bringing him in are the same who are consulting on police department improvements.

  4. Central MA

    As an outsider who follows Springfield goings-on with great interest, I have been repeatedly impressed with the intelligent, articulate, and knowledgeable approach demonstrated by Commissioner Flynn. Coming from outside the city, it seems like Springfield has been fortunate to have a man of his caliber at this historical time of change. It appears that Springfield would benefit if Flynn elects to stay for the duration of his contract. However, should he resign, Flynn has helped set the city on a positive footing if the baton now passes to Fitchet or any other selected candidate.

  5. Becca

    Heather, unfortunately in the field of search and recruitment, you don’t always find a great pool of candidates the first time around, so you expand the search a little bit. It isn’t unusual. It also isn’t unusual to want them to bring in more external candidates – they seem to have at least one internal candidate in the pool based on the press releases.

    That said, I am not in the least bit thrilled about this whole development. Don’t get me wrong!

  6. Belmont

    I would tend to agree with Central MA in that Flynn even if he left tomorrow is leaving the Police Dept in a much better state than the way he found it.

  7. Heather Brandon http://urbancompass.net

    It’s admirable and worthwhile to focus on the positives in the situation.

    Is the city’s approach to dealing with the commissioner’s position—eliminating it as a civil service job—now coming back around to bite? Or is this still the best option? How can the city find some guarantees in a level of commitment for this position, if not in the form of a high salary?

  8. Heather Brandon http://urbancompass.net

    More on Flynn’s outlook on the possible transition in this Journal Sentinel blog post.

  9. Sheila McElwaine

    Re: Flynn Quotes from Milwaukee Sentinel: Gosh, I thought Springfield had both “great, great, great set of urban challenges”and a strong community sentiment and willingness to do something about it.” I also thought that our situation would present “enough of a challenge for any police administrator to want to tackle….” Guess I missed something.

  10. Urban Compass | Blog Archive | Milwaukee TV News Cites Flynn Smear Campaign http://urbancompass.net/?p=738

    [...] deeply criticizing Springfield Police Commissioner Edward Flynn, who is currently a candidate for the post of Milwaukee police chief. Interviews are scheduled to take place tomorrow at 6:00 pm [...]

  11. Urban Compass | Blog Archive | Campaign 2007 Results: Uncertainty Prevails http://urbancompass.net/?p=783

    [...] that once Sarno takes office, he’ll likely ask for Flynn’s resignation, which would cost the city $155,000. Flynn has said he’ll just keep working his butt off in Springfield if he ends up [...]

  12. Urban Compass | Blog Archive | Commissioner Flynn Accepts Milwaukee Job Post http://urbancompass.net/?p=798

    [...] in the Republican tonight mentions talk that Deputy Chief William Fitchet—who was previously named Commissioner Flynn’s replacement as Acting Commissioner, should circumstances call for [...]

  13. Urban Compass | Blog Archive | Mayor Ryan Supports Fitchet for Police Commissioner http://urbancompass.net/?p=801

    [...] the mayor authority to appoint an acting chief should Flynn actually resign. He and Lisausakas had announced that, if necessary, they would immediately appoint Deputy Fitchet as acting [...]

Have your say:

Fields marked with * are required
Email will not be published

RSS feed for comments on this post